Year 5 NAPLAN Writing Returns to Paper in 2028

EducationDaily

Australian education ministers have agreed to return the Year 5 NAPLAN writing test to pen and paper from 2028. The decision came at a national meeting of state, territory and federal ministers on Monday, 2 November 2026. It followed a sustained push led by New South Wales Education Minister Prue Car. As a result, the move reverses a shift towards fully computerised testing that began in 2018. It also signals a rethink of how young students should demonstrate a fundamental academic skill. Specifically, that skill is the ability to compose a piece of writing independently, by hand.

What the Decision Covers

The change applies specifically to the writing component of NAPLAN. In particular, three details define its scope. First, Year 5 will revert to paper in 2028. Students in that year level will put laptops aside and complete handwritten writing exams. Second, Years 7 and 9 remain under review. Ministers have requested further independent advice before deciding whether those cohorts will also return to paper.

Finally, all other domains will stay online. Reading, numeracy and conventions of language will continue as digital assessments for every year level. Until now, only Year 3 students completed the writing test on paper. Meanwhile, Years 5, 7 and 9 sat it digitally.

The Data Behind the Reversal

The decision follows sustained concern about national writing results. However, NAPLAN is not a pass-or-fail test. Instead, it reports student achievement against four proficiency levels: Exceeding, Strong, Developing and Needs additional support. In 2026, around 38 per cent of Year 9 students sat below the Strong level in writing. Specifically, 25.6 per cent were Developing and 12.8 per cent needed additional support. At the national level, ACARA reported that results remained broadly stable, with no reportable changes in average scores since 2025. Within that picture, two separate trends stood out. First, average reading scores in Years 5, 7 and 9 were lower than in 2025. Second, the share of students needing additional support in reading and writing has risen slightly since 2023.

- Advertisement -

Technical reliability added further pressure. On 11 March 2026, a platform issue stopped students logging on to the online writing test. ACARA was notified of the problem at 9.20am AEDT and advised schools to pause testing. Testing then resumed at about 11:30am. More than 1.3 million students were scheduled to sit NAPLAN, although not all of them were affected. For example, Year 3 students write on paper, so they continued as normal. ACARA also noted that, because of time zones, about 100,000 Queensland students in Years 5, 7 and 9 had already completed the writing test. Even so, ACARA acknowledged that the disruption affected many students in Years 5, 7 and 9. As a result, it advised caution when interpreting the 2026 writing results. Separately, a 2025 glitch enabled predictive text and spellcheck during the writing test at two Sydney schools. Consequently, Year 5 students at Waverley College and Kambala had to resit the test. ACARA stressed at the time that the problem was not widespread. More than 880,000 writing tests had been submitted successfully.

The Science Supporting Handwriting

Meanwhile, supporters of the NSW proposal have pointed to research on handwriting and brain activity. For example, a study published in Frontiers in Psychology in January 2024 recorded brain activity in 36 university students. Participants wrote words by hand with a digital pen and typed the same words on a keyboard. Researchers at the Norwegian University of Science and Technology found more elaborate brain connectivity patterns during handwriting. However, the study has clear limits. It involved adults rather than primary students, and it measured brain connectivity rather than test results. In addition, it did not test whether participants remembered more after writing by hand. Therefore, it does not show that handwritten NAPLAN tests will lift writing performance. Instead, it adds context to the policy debate about how children learn to write.

“Handwriting is probably among the most complex motor skills that the brain is capable of,” Marieke Longcamp told NPR in 2024. Longcamp is a cognitive neuroscientist at Aix-Marseille Université. As NPR explained, writing by hand requires the brain to monitor and adjust the pressure of each finger on the pen. Some research also suggests children recognise letters more efficiently after writing them by hand than after typing them. Even so, researchers have not shown that handwriting alone improves literacy. For Australian primary teachers, the evidence supports handwriting as one part of early literacy teaching. On the other hand, ACARA has defended online writing assessment. In its NAPLAN Online guidance, ACARA stated that its research shows students produce writing of similar quality online and by hand at each year level. ACARA also noted that students generally value online editing features. However, some of those features, such as predictive text, are disabled during NAPLAN testing. Importantly, these findings concern writing quality in tests, not broader questions about how children learn.

A Broader Classroom Digital Detox

The debate also sits within wider concern about screens in classrooms. Federal Education Minister Jason Clare has suggested that screens and social media could be part of the problem behind falling results. Similarly, in mid-2026, education ministers asked senior officials for advice on conducting the writing test with pen and paper. According to the ministers’ communiqué, they cited emerging evidence on how screens and devices affect cognitive development.

- Advertisement -

NSW has moved furthest on this front. For instance, the NSW Government’s new guidelines recommend at least one hour a day of learning with pen and paper. These guidelines apply to NSW schools and are not a national requirement. In addition, research funded by the NSW Government into screen use found limited parental support for classroom technology. Only around one third of parents of primary-aged children said its benefits outweigh the disadvantages.

What Comes Next

Schools now have until 2028 to prepare. For many primary classrooms, this means restoring sustained handwriting practice and building stamina for extended composition. Teachers will also need training to assess handwritten work at scale. In addition, assessment authorities must print, distribute and mark paper scripts for an entire national cohort. However, test format, handwriting practice and explicit writing instruction are separate issues. Changing the test format alone will not reverse declining writing results.

Ultimately, the pending decision on Years 7 and 9 will determine how far the reversal extends. Meanwhile, the Year 5 change reflects renewed interest in handwriting among Australian policymakers. Its effect on student performance remains unknown. Therefore, education authorities will need to assess the results carefully once paper testing returns in 2028.

Share This Article